Validation

How we check FEA Studio

We model the same building in established programs and publish the differences, including the ones we haven’t closed yet. A positive number means our program gives the higher value: FEA Studio for the elastic periods, FEA OpenSees Building for pushover and time history.

Against MIDAS Gen NX

A reinforced concrete building from a Korean seismic evaluation sample (KDS 41 17 00), with fibre sections, modelled identically in both programs. Our nonlinear runs are FEA OpenSees Building’s, on OpenSees.

QuantityDifferenceNotes
Elastic natural periods+1.5 to +2.6 %All modes compared
Pushover X, peak base shear−2.6 %Whole curve within ±6 %
Pushover Y7 to 16 %Open: MIDAS is weaker and stops converging at 44 mm. Under investigation.
Time history, peak roof displacement+3 %Same ground motion
Time history, peak base shear+1 %

Against Perform3D 11

The same building in CSI Perform3D, with loads and load cases set up in Perform3D’s own interface.

QuantityDifferenceNotes
Elastic natural periodswithin 3 %Mass identical
Pushover X and Y, peak base shear+6 %At the same peak displacement
Time history, peak roof displacement+13 %Open: correlation 0.90 and the same peak time. Not the damping basis: damping on the initial stiffness, as Perform3D does, moves our peak only from 50.7 to 50.9 mm. A structure 6 % stronger that moves 13 % more points to how much energy each program dissipates per cycle.

What else is checked

Concrete design, code by code

Beam and column design is tested against hand calculations for ACI 318-19, AS 3600-2018, CSA A23.3-19, Eurocode 2, IS 456 and KDS 14 20, and cross-checked with the published method of a leading commercial program.

Load combinations

The code combinations FEA Studio writes are checked against the codes themselves and compared with the combinations ETABS and MIDAS document for the same load cases.

Every static solve

The solver scales the equations and refines the answer, then reports the residual and the largest support movement. If a fixed support moves, the run stops instead of giving you wrong numbers.

Reading other programs’ files

Our MIDAS readers are checked against dozens of model and result pairs exported by MIDAS itself.

You remain the engineer of record

FEA Studio shows its working so that you can check it. Review the model, the loads and the results with the same care you would give any calculation, and check critical members independently.

The full benchmark reports, with models and charts, are available on request. Ask for them.